United States Well being and Human Companies Secretary Robert F Kennedy Jr sparred with US senators over his administration of well being businesses and previous feedback about COVID-19 vaccines and antidepressants. At a number of factors in the course of the hours-long Senate Finance Committee listening to on Thursday, Kennedy mentioned senators have been making up data or distorting his report.
“You might be being dishonest proper now,” he advised Democrat Senator Tina Smith after she mentioned he had blamed antidepressants on a current college capturing in her dwelling state of Minnesota.
Really helpful Tales
record of 4 gadgetsfinish of record
When Republican Senator Invoice Cassidy from Louisiana mentioned the federal government was “successfully” denying individuals vaccines, Kennedy retorted, “You’re fallacious.
“You’re simply making stuff as much as scare individuals, and it’s a lie,” he mentioned to Senator Maggie Hassan, a New Hampshire Democrat who mentioned Kennedy was limiting entry to COVID-19 vaccines.
PolitiFact fact-checked a number of the most notable back-and-forth moments from Kennedy’s testimony.
What number of People died from COVID?
Senator Mark Warner requested Kennedy whether or not he accepts that “1,000,000 People died from COVID.”
“I don’t know what number of died,” Kennedy mentioned.
“You’re the secretary of Well being and Human Companies,” Warner mentioned. “You don’t have any concept what number of People died from COVID?”
“I don’t suppose anyone is aware of that as a result of there was a lot information chaos popping out of the CDC,” Kennedy mentioned.
Greater than 1 million People have died from COVID-19, in keeping with a number of statistical estimates.
Many sufferers who died had comorbidities, together with hypertension, heart problems and diabetes. Researchers say that figuring out causal relationships between comorbidities and outcomes in COVID-19 is methodologically tough.
Kennedy adjustments tune on 2020 COVID vaccine initiative
Cassidy requested Kennedy if he agreed that President Donald Trump deserves a Nobel Prize for Operation Warp Pace, Trump’s 2020 initiative that resulted within the fast growth of COVID-19 vaccines.
“Completely,” Kennedy mentioned.
Cassidy mentioned Kennedy’s help shocked him, due to Kennedy’s COVID-19 vaccine criticisms and actions. Kennedy cancelled funding for mRNA vaccine analysis, the science that led to the fast growth of the vaccine.
In 2021, Kennedy falsely mentioned the COVID-19 vaccine was the “deadliest vaccine ever made”.
Within the September 4 listening to, Kennedy mentioned that Operation Warp Pace was “genius” as a result of “it obtained the vaccine to market that was completely matched to the virus at the moment, when it was badly wanted as a result of there was low pure immunity and or individuals getting very badly injured by COVID.”
‘Everyone’ can’t get COVID-19 vaccines
Hassan mentioned Kennedy was limiting individuals’s entry to the COVID-19 vaccine.
“Individuals who need to train their freedom of alternative are being denied that since you are citing information that you simply received’t produce to the general public,” Hassan mentioned.
Kennedy pushed again.
“Everyone can get the vaccine,” Kennedy mentioned. “You’re simply making issues as much as scare individuals, and it’s a lie.”
The Meals and Drug Administration has restricted the teams of people who find themselves authorized to get essentially the most up to date COVID-19 vaccine. Anybody age 65 and older and any particular person 6 months and older who has at the least one underlying well being situation that will increase their threat of extreme COVID-19 an infection are authorized to get the 2025-26 COVID-19 vaccine, in keeping with August 27 steering.
Individuals who don’t match into these classes aren’t banned from getting a COVID-19 vaccine. However getting one may require medical doctors to prescribe the vaccine “off-label”, making the method tougher and doubtlessly extra expensive.
Kennedy’s unsupported tie of violent crime, antidepressants
Smith mentioned Kennedy blamed college shootings on antidepressants after the August 27 capturing at Annunciation Catholic Faculty in Minneapolis that killed two youngsters and injured 21 individuals. Kennedy mentioned Smith was “simply making stuff up” and he had not mentioned that.
Throughout an August 28 interview, a “Fox & Associates” host requested Kennedy if the federal government was investigating whether or not gender dysphoria medicines play a job in violent crimes. Robin Westman, the 23-year-old who fired by way of the home windows of the Minneapolis church throughout a morning Mass, was assigned male at delivery and later modified names to replicate a feminine id.
Kennedy mentioned that the Well being and Human Companies Division is “launching research on the potential contribution of a number of the SSRI medication and a number of the different psychiatric medication that is likely to be contributing to violence”. SSRI medication – selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors – are a category of antidepressant.
Kennedy beforehand has linked antidepressants to violent crime.
Psychiatry specialists have advised PolitiFact and different fact-checkers there isn’t a causal relationship between antidepressants and shootings. About 11 % of the nation’s grownup inhabitants makes use of antidepressants, in keeping with the Facilities for Illness Management and Prevention (CDC). Consultants say if there have been a hyperlink between violence and the medicines, they might count on increased charges of violence.
Senator Ben Ray Luján and RFK Jr spar over the position of vaccine skeptic David Geier at HHS
Senator Ben Ray Luján and Kennedy had a backwards and forwards over Kennedy’s hiring of David Geier, a longtime vaccine critic.
In March, the Washington Submit reported that Kennedy employed Geier to conduct a examine of hyperlinks between vaccines and autism.
Kennedy advised Luján that Geier, who’s working as a contractor, just isn’t conducting a examine. As a substitute, Kennedy mentioned Geier had entry to the Vaccine Security Datalink, “the most important repository for vaccine data”.
Kennedy didn’t specify what Geier would do with that data. Nevertheless, at an August 26 White Home Cupboard assembly, Kennedy mentioned his division would have bulletins “discovering interventions, sure interventions, now which are clearly, nearly actually, inflicting autism”.
Autism researchers and folks on the autism spectrum have advised PolitiFact that extra individuals have been identified with autism as its definition and diagnostic standards expanded over time; autism has no recognized single trigger.
Shooter who focused CDC Atlanta headquarters had psychological well being points, motivated by anger over COVID-19 vaccines
Senator Raphael Warnock introduced up the lethal August 8 capturing on the CDC’s headquarters in Atlanta, asking Kennedy if he had been to the campus as well being secretary earlier than the capturing.
“No,” Kennedy responded. Kennedy did go to the campus after the capturing, however no workers have been there.
Patrick Joseph White, 30, died from a self-inflicted gunshot wound after he fired practically 200 rounds of ammunition, killing responding DeKalb County Police Officer David Rose.
Officers with the Georgia Bureau of Investigation mentioned they recovered “written documentation” displaying that White distrusted the COVID-19 vaccine and blamed it for making him depressed and suicidal.
Senator Invoice Cassidy fact-checks RFK Jr’s statistics about conflicts of curiosity on vaccine panel
Whereas talking a few want for brand new CDC management, Kennedy mentioned it’s “crucial that we take away officers with conflicts of curiosity and catastrophically dangerous judgment and political agendas”.
Later within the listening to, Senator Invoice Cassidy advised Kennedy he was fallacious concerning the degree of battle of curiosity within the vaccine panel whose 17 members Kennedy not too long ago fired.
“It was not 97 % as alleged, moderately, it was 6.9 %,” Cassidy mentioned.
To be on the CDC’s Advisory Committee on Immunisation Practices, members are required to declare conflicts of curiosity. At every assembly and prior to each vote, members are once more requested to reveal conflicts of curiosity and to abstain from voting if they’ve one.
The CDC has revealed the conflicts of curiosity disclosed by every member at each assembly from 2000 to 2024.
An August 18 analysis report revealed within the Journal of the American Medical Affiliation analysed conflicts of curiosity within the ACIP and the Meals and Drug Administration’s Vaccines and Associated Organic Merchandise Advisory Committee over the previous 20 years. Researchers discovered conflicts of curiosity have dropped. Conflicts of curiosity within the ACIP fell to five % in 2024.
Trainer’s union didn’t write an order to shut colleges.
Kennedy mentioned “the CDC allowed the academics union to put in writing the order to shut colleges” in the course of the COVID-19 pandemic.
That is deceptive.
The American Federation of Academics, the second largest trainer’s union within the US, consulted with the CDC in 2021 on its college reopening steering, nevertheless it didn’t “write” the order to shut down colleges firstly of the pandemic.
A Home Choose Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic, spearheaded by Republicans, investigated whether or not the union had influenced the CDC’s college reopening coverage.
In accordance with the committee, the CDC in February 2021 shared a draft copy of its college reopening steering with the trainer’s union and added a union-requested set off that known as for closing colleges if COVID-19 circumstances reached a sure threshold.
In accordance with a Democratic memo that Politico reported on in 2023, the CDC consulted a number of stakeholders earlier than the union was conscious of the steering.
The CDC consulted about 50 organisations whereas creating its steering, in keeping with the memo, didn’t invite the trainer’s union to a discussion board to assist preview the steering, and the union acquired the draft days after the CDC despatched it to a number of different teams for suggestions. The union testified, Politico reported, that it realized concerning the draft steering from The New York Occasions.
Analysis reveals fluoride in water at advisable ranges is secure
Kennedy touted his actions on “fluoride in our ingesting water” throughout his opening assertion. In April, Kennedy mentioned he would advise the CDC to cease recommending fluoridated ingesting water after misleadingly linking it to most cancers and different well being dangers.
The CDC has lengthy touted fluoridated ingesting water as one of many best public well being achievements of the twentieth century. Analysis reveals that ingesting fluoridated water at america’ advisable ranges – 0.7 milligrams per litre – is secure and prevents cavities and tooth decay. Well being dangers related to fluoride are tied to increased ranges of publicity than what’s permitted in US ingesting water.
A new Florida legislation eliminated fluoride from ingesting water, overriding native insurance policies, this summer season.