Join Chalkbeat’s free weekly e-newsletter to maintain up with how training is altering throughout the U.S.
Former Tennessee Training Commissioner Penny Schwinn has been named to function deputy training secretary within the incoming Trump administration.
President-elect Donald Trump introduced the choose in a put up on Fact Social Friday night. He described Schwinn as having a “sturdy report of delivering outcomes for youngsters and households.” He additionally misstated her title as Peggy Schwinn, somewhat than Penny.
Schwinn – who began her profession as a Train for America corps member in Baltimore, based a constitution college, and served in high-level administrative roles in a number of states and on the College of Florida – would carry intensive training expertise to the position, in distinction with Trump’s training secretary choose, World Wrestling Leisure co-founder Linda McMahon.
“Penny is a real conservative with a superb thoughts for training,” Tennessee Gov. Invoice Lee wrote on the social media website X. “Tennessee benefited from her service & now our nation will.”
Schwinn served on the helm of the Tennessee Division of Training throughout a pivotal time when the state overhauled its college funding components and its strategy to literacy instruction amid the disruptions of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Her tenure was additionally marked by controversy, with excessive turnover within the training division and a no-bid contract to an organization charged with managing the state’s incoming pilot voucher program. State lawmakers steadily complained that she launched new initiatives with out acceptable session.
Schwinn fell afoul of cultural conservatives who felt she didn’t do sufficient to ferret out progressive approaches to educating race and historical past within the state’s faculties. A proposal to make use of federal cash to conduct “well-being checks” on Tennessee youngsters not at school alarmed mother and father’ rights advocates.
The conservative Tennessee Star on Saturday highlighted her affiliation with members of the “By no means Trump” motion. Even a few of her extra reasonable critics expressed shock on the appointment.
“If anyone regarded into her background, they’d say she was not a match for this administration,” mentioned JC Bowman, govt director of Skilled Educators of Tennessee and a frequent critic of Schwinn throughout her time as state training chief. “So I didn’t see it coming. Whoever vetted her must be vetted.”
All through her profession, Bowman instructed Chalkbeat, Schwinn “has been all up and down the ideological spectrum,” relying on who she was working for.
“I don’t dispute that she’s a tough employee,” he mentioned. “No matter agenda she’s given, she’ll put within the effort to do it.”
Trump staffing up training division he desires to abolish
There may be important uncertainty over the form of training coverage within the subsequent Trump administration. As a candidate, Trump pledged to dismantle the U.S. Division of Training and to take away “woke ideologies” from American school rooms. His marketing campaign portrayed academics as “groomers” recruiting youngsters to vary their gender and opposed insurance policies that promoted inclusion for transgender college students.
However neither of his two management picks thus far, McMahon and Schwinn, have monitor data as cultural conservatives. McMahon has spoken in favor of personal college alternative, apprenticeships, and higher workforce training. Since leaving the Tennessee training division, Schwinn has continued to advocate for bettering literacy instruction.
In an op-ed in The 74 this summer time with Maryland State Superintendent of Faculties Carey Wright, Schwinn advocated for the creation of a Nationwide Heart for Superior Improvement in Training on the Institute of Training Sciences, the analysis arm of the U.S. Division of Training.
Disseminating analysis and finest practices is a serious position of the federal division that Trump ostensibly desires to eradicate. Truly eliminating the division would require an act of Congress, which appears unlikely. Since being elected, Trump has referred typically to returning training to the states, which already management most facets of training coverage. Schwinn would carry the attitude of a state faculties chief to her job.
Deputy and assistant secretaries of federal companies can play a serious position in shaping coverage, significantly when the secretary, like McMahon, has restricted expertise. Observers are watching to see who Trump appoints to go civil rights enforcement inside faculties.
Schwinn’s tenure in Tennessee marked by victories, controversies
Schwinn joined the Lee administration in 2019 and served by means of 2023. On the time of her departure, she instructed Chalkbeat the pandemic represented her best problem. Tennessee drew nationwide reward for applications that focused pandemic aid to college students who suffered a few of the worst setbacks.
“Once we take a look at the final 4 and a half years and the gorgeous unbelievable challenges that we’ve confronted in training throughout this nation, I can not consider a state that has proven extra management than Tennessee,” she mentioned on the time.
Schwinn’s profession has been marked by a fast rise since she began in Baltimore in 2004 with Train for America, a program that locations school graduates in high-needs faculties and encourages its alums to pursue management roles in training. She later based Capitol Collegiate Academy, a constitution college in her hometown of Sacramento, California, the place she nonetheless serves on the board of administrators. Schwinn served briefly in management roles for Sacramento’s college district and Delaware’s division of training earlier than changing into chief deputy commissioner of teachers for Texas in 2016.
In Tennessee, she helped Lee ship on a rewrite of the state’s 30-year-old training funding components to let funding observe the coed, and put aside more cash for college kids with greater wants. She additionally shepherded a number of new initiatives, together with a complete plan to enhance literacy, assist college students get well from pandemic studying loss, and develop grow-your-own instructor coaching applications.
However in her first 9 months on the job, practically a fifth of the training division’s workers left, largely from resignations. She additionally pissed off lawmakers who mentioned she rolled out initiatives and took administrative shortcuts with out ample legislative enter, assessment, or approval.
As Tennessee expanded its voucher program, Schwinn tapped a high aide with expertise working related applications in Florida.
Schwinn most lately served as vice chairman of the College of Florida, working with former Republican senator and college president Ben Sasse. Schwinn labored remotely from Tennessee in a new place connecting college applications and Okay-12 faculties. After Sasse abruptly resigned his place in July 2024, Schwinn was not re-appointed.
Erica Meltzer is Chalkbeat’s nationwide editor based mostly in Colorado. Contact Erica at emeltzer@chalkbeat.org.
Marta Aldrich is a senior correspondent and covers the statehouse for Chalkbeat Tennessee. Contact her at maldrich@chalkbeat.org.