Join Chalkbeat New York’s free each day publication to get important information about NYC’s public faculties delivered to your inbox.
This text is a part of an ongoing collaboration between Chalkbeat and THE CITY.
Hallways on the Stewart Resort, a midtown Manhattan shelter for migrant households, are sometimes bustling on weekday mornings with youngsters and oldsters on their strategy to college.
They have been eerily empty on Thursday morning.
An analogous scene performed out on the close by Roosevelt Resort shelter and consumption middle, the place a line of migrant households ready to get again inside following college pickup was far shorter than regular Thursday afternoon. The vast majority of youngsters stayed residence “due to that concern,” mentioned one father in Spanish.
And in Bushwick, Brooklyn, one dad who warily despatched his youngsters to highschool mentioned he was within the minority of households on the shelter to take action.
“Virtually no person is sending their youngsters [to school] in case they’re taken,” mentioned Amanda, a Venezuelan mom staying on the Stewart who stored her three youngsters out of faculty all week and requested to make use of solely her first title out of concern of jeopardizing her immigration case. She estimated that about 100 youngsters on the shelter stayed out of faculty this week. “Everyone seems to be scared.”
On excessive alert after President Donald Trump’s inauguration this week and fearful about his promise to fast-track deportations, scores of immigrant households stored their youngsters residence from college, a number of dad and mom mentioned.
Educators are working onerous to reassure anxious dad and mom that their youngsters shall be protected at school, in response to interviews with eight college leaders, because the New York Metropolis’s Schooling Division prohibits federal legislation enforcement brokers from getting into faculties besides beneath slender circumstances. However they’re additionally grappling with how you can quell considerations at a time when federal motion appears to be ramping up by the day.
As quickly as Trump took workplace, he rescinded a longstanding inside coverage prohibiting Immigration and Customs Enforcement, or ICE, from making arrests at “delicate areas” like church buildings and faculties, additional heightening fears for households. His pledge to start mass deportations of tens of millions of undocumented immigrants nationwide hit near residence on Thursday when immigration officers launched a office raid throughout the Hudson River in Newark. Chicago Public Faculties officers mentioned Friday that brokers confirmed up at a Chicago elementary college however college workers barred them from getting into.
It’s troublesome to know what number of households throughout the 5 boroughs are preserving their youngsters out of faculty due to deportation fears. An estimated 48,000 newcomers have enrolled in metropolis faculties since summer time 2022.
Each day attendance, which averaged 90% final 12 months, dipped to the mid-80s on Tuesday and Wednesday earlier than rebounding to 89% Thursday, in response to each day attendance information from the Schooling Division, although different components together with the frigid temperatures and Regents Exams administration for top schoolers probably performed a task.
Some educators are sounding the alarm that fears of immigration enforcement may preserve youngsters out of faculty in giant numbers — and can take a psychological toll on the youngsters who do present up.
“I can not inform you what number of dad and mom have come to me right now … Youngsters don’t need to come to highschool,” a guardian coordinator at a Corona, Queens, college with a big immigrant inhabitants, advised Mayor Eric Adams at a city corridor this week. “Youngsters are scared to depart residence and never come again to see their dad and mom.”
“We’re very clear, youngsters ought to go to highschool,” Adams responded. “We’re going to proceed to face up for all New Yorkers, documented and undocumented.”
However Adams has additionally cultivated an more and more shut relationship with Trump, sitting down along with his “Border Czar” to debate shared priorities, visiting Trump in Mar-A-Lago, and attending the inauguration in Washington, D.C., on Monday. Adams, who was indicted on federal corruption prices final 12 months and will theoretically obtain a pardon from Trump, has mentioned his efforts to cooperate with the brand new administration are for the good thing about the town, and that his focus for immigration enforcement is on individuals who have dedicated crimes.
The mayor has mentioned he won’t criticize Trump publicly, and declined to take a stance on Trump’s resolution to open the door to ICE making arrests at faculties — a place some educators mentioned undercuts his makes an attempt to reassure educators and immigrant households.
“I didn’t really feel like my establishment was being protected,” mentioned Lorenzo Chambers, the principal of P.S. 279 in Brooklyn, referring to Adams’ response to a query about immigration enforcement at faculties and different delicate areas. “I feel [he’s] enjoying politics with it — and he’s on each side.”
Principals battle to reassure cautious households
Principals are making ready steering counselors to work with college students who concern that their households might be deported, internet hosting data classes with households about their rights, and reminding college workers of metropolis guidelines that forbid sharing data with federal immigration officers or offering entry to the constructing and not using a warrant.
One Manhattan center college principal fielded an early morning cellphone name this week from a mom fearful about touring to drop off her daughter. The principal, who spoke on situation of anonymity out of concern that his college might be focused by immigration officers, reassured the mother that regardless of the tip of the federal coverage limiting immigration arrests at faculties, he would do every thing doable to guard college students.
“ICE goes to need to arrest me earlier than they arrest your daughter,” he advised the mother, including that they’d lock her daughter in his workplace if wanted. The mom ended up bringing her youngster to highschool.
Dan Steinberg, co-principal of Harlem Hyperlink Constitution Faculty, mentioned the college is ensuring that it has correct contact data for households within the occasion that immigration officers arrive and the college must rapidly attain caregivers.
“We hope nothing occurs however we will’t promise households that nobody goes to point out up,” Steinberg mentioned.
A number of migrant dad and mom on the Roosevelt Resort in midtown the town has used as its migrant arrival middle since 2023 mentioned staff on the shelter hadn’t supplied a lot reassurance about potential immigration raids as households tried to piece collectively data from information studies, social media posts, and panicked conversations in WhatsApp teams.
Even dad and mom who mentioned that their youngsters’s faculties had clearly communicated their plans to guard college students mentioned that they weren’t satisfied.
“They inform us to convey them, that they’ll be protected,” mentioned one Venezuelan mom on the Stewart, one other midtown lodge getting used as a shelter.
“However we’re very scared, so higher to attend a pair days to see what occurs, continued the mom, who declined to share her title for concern of immigration penalties.
Most college leaders mentioned they felt the steering from the town Schooling Division has been useful and clear. However that doesn’t make it any much less bewildering attempting to maintain up with the fast-changing information on the federal stage.
“I don’t know the way ready you may be when day-after-day you’re listening to one thing else,” mentioned a principal at a Manhattan college that’s enrolled many migrant college students, who spoke on the situation of anonymity as a result of they’re not approved to speak to the media.
Attendance struggles predate this week
Whereas a number of principals mentioned it’s too early to inform whether or not attendance has taken a giant hit this week due to immigration considerations, some famous attendance boundaries for migrant college students that pre-dated Trump. These embrace housing instability and the metropolis’s 60-day shelter eviction coverage, which frequently ends in households shifting across the metropolis and lacking days of faculty at a time as they battle to settle in and safe transportation, principals mentioned. (Metropolis officers not too long ago mentioned they’re amending the coverage to offer households who’ve already gotten one 60-day discover a reprieve). Youngsters are additionally typically pulled out of faculty for obligations like courtroom dates.
One Manhattan principal mentioned households generally depart the town with out discover, leaving the college accountable for verifying that they’ve enrolled in a brand new college earlier than discharging them. The principal added that they fearful that extra households are “going to enter hiding” now that Trump is in workplace.
Lacking even a couple of further days of faculty can really feel like a giant setback for teenagers nonetheless attempting to settle in and be taught a brand new language.
Samantha, a first-grader staying on the Stewart, mentioned she enjoys studying, writing, and drawing at college, however has resorted to watching her pill all day this week since her mother has stored her residence due to deportation fears.
A mother of a 4-year-old who hasn’t been to highschool this week mentioned, “It’s very troublesome as a result of she’s used to her associates, to enjoying.”
For the households who did determine to ship their youngsters, the choice typically got here with intense nervousness.
Gleinjer, a Venezuelan mom of three on the Stewart, determined to ship her youngsters to highschool Thursday after initially preserving them residence. Her oldest, an eighth-grader, made certain to plug in her cellphone totally the night time earlier than so she may contact her mother in case immigration officers confirmed up, Gleinjer mentioned.
“She mentioned, ‘Mommy, I charged my cellphone. … Something occurs, and I’ll name you,’” Gleinjer mentioned in Spanish. “She’s scared.” (That underscored latest considerations from State Schooling Commissioner Betty Rosa about how a looming statewide ban of cell telephones in faculties may restrict communication between migrant caregivers and their youngsters.)
Jehinzo Gonzalez, the daddy of two school-aged youngsters at a shelter in Bushwick, mentioned he’s continued to take the youngsters to highschool at the same time as leaving them there now fills him with dread. He’s photocopied his youngsters’ asylum paperwork and different immigration paperwork to maintain of their backpacks.
On a latest afternoon they have been a couple of minutes late at dismissal and he panicked.
“I used to be scared, I used to be fearful. I didn’t know if one thing had occurred,” he mentioned. “So it’s true it’s inflicting a lot anguish, and there’s such concern and uncertainty. However we preserve combating, and hoping that issues will prove OK.”
Michael Elsen-Rooney is a reporter for Chalkbeat New York, overlaying NYC public faculties. Contact Michael at melsen-rooney@chalkbeat.org
Gwynne Hogan covers Brooklyn for THE CITY.
Alex Zimmerman is a reporter for Chalkbeat New York, overlaying NYC public faculties. Contact Alex at azimmerman@chalkbeat.org.