This story first appeared in KFF Well being Information and is republished right here with permission.
Join Chalkbeat’s free weekly publication to maintain up with how schooling is altering throughout the U.S.
Jen Fisher can do solely a lot to maintain her son secure from the kinds of infections that kids can encounter at college. The remainder, she mentioned, is as much as different college students and oldsters of their hometown of Franklin, Tennessee.
Fisher’s son Raleigh, 12, lives with a congenital coronary heart situation, which has left him with a weakened immune system. For his safety, Raleigh has acquired all of the really helpful vaccines for a kid his age. However even together with his vaccinations, a virus that may solely sideline one other youngster may sicken him and land him within the emergency room, Fisher mentioned.
“We would like everybody to be vaccinated in order that diseases like measles and issues which have mainly been eradicated don’t come again,” Fisher mentioned. “These can actually have a really adversarial impact on Raleigh.”
For a lot of Raleigh’s life, Fisher may take consolation within the excessive childhood vaccination price in Tennessee — a public well being shiny spot in a conservative state with poor well being outcomes and one of many shortest life expectations within the nation.
Mississippi and West Virginia, two equally conservative states with poor well being outcomes and quick life expectations, even have a few of the highest vaccination charges for kindergartners within the nation — a seeming contradiction that stems from the truth that childhood vaccination necessities don’t at all times align with states’ different traits, mentioned James Colgrove, a Columbia College professor who research elements that affect public well being.
“The sorts of insurance policies that states have don’t map neatly on to ‘purple’ versus ‘blue’ or one area or one other,” Colgrove mentioned.
Extra mother and father opting out of vaccines for teenagers
Advocates, docs, public well being officers, and researchers fear such public well being shiny spots in some states are fading: Many states have lately reported a rise in folks opting out of vaccines for his or her youngsters as Individuals’ views shift.
Through the 2023-24 faculty yr, the proportion of kindergartners exempted from a number of vaccinations rose to three.3%, the very best ever reported, with will increase in 40 states and Washington, D.C., in response to Facilities for Illness Management and Prevention information. Tennessee and Mississippi have been amongst these with will increase. Practically all exemptions nationally have been for nonmedical causes.
Vaccine proponents fear anti-vaccine messaging may speed up a rising “well being freedom” motion that has been pushed by leaders in states comparable to Florida. Momentum towards vaccines is more likely to proceed to develop with the election of Donald Trump as president and his proposed nomination of anti-vaccine activist Robert F. Kennedy Jr. as secretary of the Division of Well being and Human Companies.
Pediatricians in states with excessive exemption charges, comparable to Florida and Georgia, say they’re involved by what they see — declining immunization ranges for kindergartners, which may result in a resurgence in vaccine-preventable illnesses comparable to measles. The Florida Division of Well being reported nonmedical exemption charges as excessive as 50% for youngsters in some areas.
“The non secular exemption is big,” mentioned Brandon Chatani, a pediatric infectious illness physician in Orlando. “That has allowed for a simple means for these youngsters to enter faculties with out vaccines.”
In lots of states, it’s simpler to get a spiritual exemption than a medical one, which regularly requires signoff from a physician.
Over the previous decade, California, Connecticut, Maine, and New York have eliminated non secular and philosophical exemptions from faculty vaccination necessities. West Virginia has not had them.
Idaho, Alaska, and Utah had the very best exemption charges for the 2023-24 faculty yr, in response to the CDC. These states permit mother and father or authorized guardians to exempt their kids for non secular causes by submitting a notarized kind or a signed assertion.
Florida and Georgia, with a few of the lowest reported minimal vaccination charges for kindergartners, permit mother and father to exempt their kids by submitting a kind with the kid’s faculty or day care.
Each states have reported declines in uptake of the measles, mumps, and rubella vaccine, which is among the most typical childhood photographs. In Georgia, MMR protection for kindergartners dropped to 88.4% within the 2023-24 faculty yr from 93.1% in 2019-20, in response to the CDC. Florida dropped to 88.1% from 93.5% throughout the identical interval.
Andi Shane, a pediatric infectious illness specialist in Atlanta, traces Georgia’s declining charges to households who lack entry to a pediatrician. State insurance policies on exemptions are additionally key, she mentioned.
“There’s plenty of information to assist the truth that when private perception exemptions should not permitted, that vaccination charges are increased,” she mentioned.
Mississippi begins permitting non secular exemptions
In December, Georgia public well being officers put out an advisory saying the state had recorded considerably extra whooping cough instances than within the prior yr. In accordance with CDC information, Georgia reported 280 instances in 2024 in contrast with 96 the yr earlier than.
Till 2023, Mississippi was one of many few states that allowed mother and father to decide out of vaccinating their youngsters just for medical causes — and solely with the approval of a physician. That gave it among the many highest vaccination charges within the nation as of the 2023-24 faculty yr.
“It’s one of many few issues Mississippi has finished properly,” mentioned Anita Henderson, a pediatrician who has practiced within the southern a part of the state for almost 30 years. By way of well being, she mentioned, childhood vaccination charges have been the state’s one “shining star.”
However that modified in April 2023 when a federal decide ordered state officers to begin permitting non secular exemptions. The ruling has emboldened many households, Henderson mentioned.
“We’re seeing an increasing number of skepticism, an increasing number of vaccine hesitancy, and a insecurity due to this ruling,” she mentioned.
State officers have granted greater than 5,000 non secular exemptions for the reason that court docket order permitting them, in response to the state well being division. Daniel Edney, the state well being officer, mentioned a lot of the requests have come from “extra prosperous” residents in “pockets” of the state.
“Most individuals take heed to the professional opinions of their pediatricians and household medication docs to remain on the vaccine schedule, as a result of it’s what’s finest to guard their kids,” he mentioned.
West Virginia’s vaccine legislation — which hasn’t allowed nonmedical exemptions — additionally may quickly change, Matthew Christiansen mentioned in December earlier than he resigned because the state’s well being officer.
A invoice that might have broadened exemptions made it by way of the legislature final yr however was vetoed by outgoing Republican Gov. Jim Justice. The brand new governor, Republican Pat Morrisey, has been a vocal critic of vaccine mandates. And only a day after being inaugurated, he issued an govt order to suggest provisions by Feb. 1 that might permit non secular and conscientious exemptions.
“I need to ship a message that when you’ve got a spiritual perception, then we’re going to have an exception,” he mentioned at a Tuesday press convention. “We’re not going to be the outlier.”
Folks asserting their private freedoms to say no vaccines for his or her youngsters can finally curtail the power of others to stay full lives, Christiansen mentioned. “Youngsters getting measles and mumps and polio and being paralyzed for his or her entire life is an obstacle on private freedom and autonomy for these youngsters,” he mentioned.
Because the Covid pandemic, anti-vaccine sentiment has been rising in Tennessee. One group, Stand for Well being Freedom, drafted a letter for constituents to ship to their state lawmakers calling for the resignation of the medical director of Tennessee’s Vaccine-Preventable Illnesses and Immunization Program. The group mentioned she demonstrated a “lack of respect for the knowledgeable consent rights” of the folks.
“They really feel emboldened by the concept that this presidential administration appears to really feel very strongly that loads of these points must be taken again to the states,” mentioned Emily Delikat, director of Tennessee Households for Vaccines, a pro-vaccine group.
Finally, like many efficient public well being interventions, vaccines are a sufferer of their very own success, mentioned Henderson, the Mississippi pediatrician. Most individuals haven’t seen outbreaks of measles or polio, in order that they neglect how harmful the illnesses are, she mentioned.
“It could sadly take a resurgence of these illnesses to boost consciousness to the truth that these are harmful, these are lethal, these are preventable,” she mentioned. “I hope it doesn’t come to that.”
Daniel Chang and Sam Whitehead are reporters with KFF Well being Information, Healthbeat’s nationwide reporting companion. Healthbeat is a nonprofit newsroom protecting public well being printed by Civic Information Firm, which additionally publishes Chalkbeat. Join Healthbeat’s newsletters right here.