Join Chalkbeat New York’s free each day e-newsletter to get important information about NYC’s public faculties delivered to your inbox.
Within the 9 years since New York Metropolis handed a groundbreaking regulation requiring public faculties to offer free menstrual merchandise in bogs, the Schooling Division has constantly “did not ship” on its authorized obligation, a lawsuit filed final week in Manhattan alleges.
The 2016 laws was the first within the nation to require center and excessive faculties to offer free tampons and sanitary pads in bogs.
However within the ensuing years, metropolis Schooling Division officers violated that regulation “at each flip,” failing to adequately talk the brand new authorized obligation to colleges or guarantee they have been complying, in accordance with the go well with filed on behalf of the nonprofit Interval Regulation and an unnamed teenage pupil. In consequence, college students throughout the town nonetheless routinely miss class time as a result of they don’t have entry to menstrual merchandise — and when they’re obtainable, college students typically don’t learn about them or don’t need to use them as a result of they’re so low-quality, the go well with mentioned.
“The Division [of Education]’s failure to guard the wants of its menstruating college students — regardless of a near-decade-long authorized mandate — is each illegal and willful,” in accordance with the lawsuit, which was filed by the regulation agency Sullivan & Cromwell in Manhattan Supreme Courtroom.
Final November, after Metropolis Council intervention and threats of authorized motion, the town Schooling Division revealed long-awaited compliance information. However the metropolis’s report “falsely claimed that the Division had achieved 100% compliance,” the go well with claims.
The go well with requested the decide to order the Schooling Division to put aside a chosen finances to adjust to the regulation, rent an impartial adviser to watch its progress, and re-do its information reporting on school-by-school compliance.
Neither the town Schooling nor Regulation Division replied to a request for touch upon the lawsuit.
At a 2023 Metropolis Council listening to, Schooling Division college services chief John Shea known as stories of unstocked dispensers “unacceptable” and mentioned faculties ought to escalate complaints to his workplace. The Schooling Division has offered a “Know Your Interval” pupil information to each college, which walks college students by means of how to answer their intervals, in accordance with the town’s information.
NYC’s menstrual fairness regulation breaks new floor
A 2019 nationwide survey discovered nearly all of ladies throughout the nation didn’t have entry to free menstrual merchandise of their excessive faculties and missed college extra regularly in consequence.
Many women don’t know when their intervals will begin and don’t carry provides from dwelling, and the price of menstrual merchandise can put them out of attain for others — a very acute drawback in a system the place greater than 70% of scholars stay in poverty. Estimates of the typical value of a month’s provide of menstrual merchandise vary from about $9 to $15.
Town’s 2016 regulation “was meant to place menstrual merchandise on par with lavatory merchandise wanted by all college students no matter intercourse, similar to rest room paper and cleaning soap,” in accordance with the go well with.
However from the outset, implementation was spotty, advocates and attorneys mentioned.
The Schooling Division’s solely communication with faculties concerning the regulation in 2016 was a brief blurb within the weekly Principal’s Digest that failed to say the authorized requirement, in accordance with a public data request filed by Interval Regulation.
Division officers largely positioned accountability for complying with the regulation within the arms of custodian engineers, who have been purported to obtain the menstrual merchandise and dispensers and replenish them once they ran low, in accordance with the go well with.
However officers did little to make sure faculties have been complying, and it typically fell to college students to ask for refills, in accordance with the go well with. Efforts to unfold the phrase concerning the initiative by means of flyers have been woefully inadequate, the go well with added.
Within the meantime, a number of enterprising pupil teams took oversight into their very own arms. A Brooklyn Lady Scout troop visited faculties in 2018 and located fewer than 1 in 5 had sufficient provides and disposal bins. An award-winning Bronx center college podcast reported that college students nonetheless needed to go to the workplace and use a code phrase to get pads.
NYC Council steps up the strain
Lengthy-simmering complaints concerning the metropolis’s lack of compliance got here to the fore throughout a 2023 Metropolis Council listening to. A number of lawmakers mentioned they’d personally visited a number of faculties and located no menstrual merchandise within the bogs. Interval Regulation revealed that in a latest survey of metropolis highschool college students, 85% mentioned they nonetheless lacked entry to menstrual merchandise at college.
College students mentioned that contributed to an ongoing sense of stigma and disgrace about intervals.
“My college didn’t present menstrual merchandise, and my classroom didn’t make it a cushty place to debate what any of us have been experiencing,” mentioned Gabriela Lopez Castillo, a latest faculty graduate and youth advocate for the group PERIOD, who testified on the 2023 listening to.
The go well with additionally cites 18 examples from 2024 and 2025 of New York Metropolis educators creating crowdfunding campaigns to purchase menstrual merchandise for college kids who in any other case wouldn’t have entry to them at college.
In December 2023, the council handed a package deal of recent payments meant to shore up the regulation, increasing the mandate to cowl elementary faculties, and requiring the Schooling Division to publicly report on compliance by July 5, 2024. The Schooling Division blew previous that deadline and solely revealed the info in November after Interval Regulation threatened authorized motion, in accordance with the go well with.
Town’s information mentioned 100% of colleges complied with the regulation for the 2023-2024 college 12 months — a rivalry attorneys say is “clearly and demonstrably false” given the in depth testimony about lack of entry to menstrual merchandise within the September 2023 council listening to.
The go well with suggests quite a few attainable treatments, together with forcing the Schooling Division to work with Interval Regulation to enhance its information assortment and making a working group of advocates and officers to supervise compliance.
Michael Elsen-Rooney is a reporter for Chalkbeat New York, masking NYC public faculties. Contact Michael at melsen-rooney@chalkbeat.org.